Publishing Options:
Traditional vs. Self-Publishing for Fiction Authors

Read more Writing a novel

Publishing Options

For fiction authors, the journey to getting their work into the hands of readers begins with an important decision: choosing between traditional publishing and self-publishing. Each path offers unique opportunities and challenges, and understanding the differences between the two can greatly influence a writer's success and satisfaction with their publishing journey. In this blog entry, we explore the pros and cons of traditional and self-publishing for fiction authors, helping writers make an informed choice that aligns with their goals and aspirations.

Traditional Publishing

  1. Credibility and Validation
    One of the main advantages of traditional publishing is the credibility and validation it provides. Being accepted by a reputable publishing house signals that your work has been vetted by professionals in the industry, which can boost your book's reputation and attract a broader readership. Traditional publishers have established relationships with distributors, bookstores, and media, which can lead to increased visibility and marketing opportunities.
  2. Editorial and Marketing Support
    Traditional publishing offers access to professional editors, cover designers, and marketing teams who can help polish and promote your work. This support can enhance the overall quality of your book and increase its chances of success in the competitive market.
  3. Advance and Royalties
    Traditional publishing typically involves receiving an advance against future royalties. While advances can vary widely, they provide authors with an upfront payment for their work. Additionally, authors earn royalties on book sales, which can be a stable source of income if the book performs well.
  4. Distribution Reach
    Traditional publishers have an established distribution network that enables your book to reach a wide range of bookstores, libraries, and online retailers. This broad reach can expose your work to a larger audience and increase the chances of getting your book into the hands of readers.


  1. Creative Control
    Self-publishing grants authors full creative control over their work. From cover design to the final content, the author can make all decisions without compromise. This allows writers to stay true to their vision and voice, making self-publishing an attractive option for those seeking artistic freedom.
  2. Faster Time to Market
    Self-publishing allows authors to bypass the lengthy submission and selection process of traditional publishing. Once the manuscript is ready, authors can publish their book relatively quickly, making it available to readers faster.
  3. Higher Royalties
    Unlike traditional publishing, where authors typically receive a percentage of book sales as royalties, self-published authors can earn a higher percentage of the book's profits. This can be especially advantageous if the book gains popularity and generates substantial sales.
  4. Access to Publishing Platforms
    Self-publishing platforms like Amazon Kindle Direct Publishing (KDP) and IngramSpark provide easy access to a vast global audience. Authors can publish e-books, print-on-demand paperbacks, and even audiobooks through these platforms, expanding their reach to readers around the world.
  5. Direct Reader Interaction
    Self-published authors have the opportunity to directly interact with their readers through social media, newsletters, and book events. Building a loyal fanbase and understanding reader preferences can help authors tailor their future works and marketing strategies.

Challenges and Considerations

While both traditional and self-publishing have their merits, each option comes with its own set of challenges and considerations.

  • Traditional Publishing Challenges:
    • Querying and Rejection: The process of finding a literary agent and securing a publishing deal can be time-consuming and may involve facing rejection.
    • Loss of Control: Traditional publishers may request changes to your manuscript, cover design, or marketing strategy that don't align with your original vision.
    • Slower Timeframe: Traditional publishing can take several months or even years from acceptance to book release.

  • Self-Publishing Considerations:
    • Full Responsibility: As a self-published author, you are responsible for all aspects of the publishing process, including editing, marketing, and distribution.
    • Initial Investment: Self-publishing may require upfront investments for professional editing, cover design, and marketing efforts.
    • Visibility: Without the marketing support of a traditional publisher, self-published authors must work harder to gain visibility and reach their target audience.

In Conclusion

The decision between traditional publishing and self-publishing is a personal one that depends on a writer's goals, preferences, and resources. Traditional publishing offers credibility, editorial support, and broad distribution, but it comes with the challenge of securing a deal and potentially sacrificing creative control. On the other hand, self-publishing grants artistic freedom, faster time to market, and higher royalties, but it requires authors to take on all aspects of the publishing process independently.

Ultimately, the best choice for a fiction author will depend on their unique circumstances and ambitions. With the rise of hybrid publishing models, where authors can combine elements of both traditional and self-publishing, writers now have even more flexibility in tailoring their publishing journey to suit their individual needs. Whichever path they choose, authors should approach the publishing process with dedication, passion, and a commitment to producing the best possible work for their readers.

Happy writing!

Start writing with TwelvePoint

Download on the Mac App Store
(Mac Intel, Apple Silicon)
Download on the App Store
(iPhone, iPad, Apple Vision Pro)

Our community

Remember that you can always reach us via e-mail or on social networks: Instagram, 𝕏, Patreon.
We constantly update TwelvePoint to provide you with state-of-the-art screenwriting software. The feedback from our community is considered when developing new functionalities or removing those that are not needed anymore.

Learn more: Screenwriting Software | Write anywhere with TwelvePoint